Spinning Vs. Casting Reel for Surf Fishing

It is often hard to decide the type of reel one would prefer using in fishing. The two reels that we are concerned about are the spinning reel and surfing reel. These two reels possess unique properties that differentiate them from each other and other types of reels.

There are a lot of techniques which you can master, and this gives you an advantage over other forms of reels. Make sure you purchase the aluminum kind to ensure you easily detect light bites.

We intend to choose a favorite between the two by making a comparison. To do that we must first familiarize ourselves with the peculiarities of the two reels:

casting real

The Spinning Reel

Most reels in the market today, for heavy duty work and durability, are made with aluminum. There are others made with graphite, which are the cheaper and less durable variant of the reels. The spinning reel is made from aluminum for some reasons.

One of the reasons spinning reels are popular today is because they are suitable for off-shore fishing. They are less prone to corrosion by salt water and are ideal for deep sea fishing. One can say that the aluminum make came in handy.

casting real

Asides being resistant to corrosion, spinning reels are very durable and strong. In this aspect, its key features are the ability to hold more massive lines and lures, which is also due to its sturdy build. One spinning reel remarkable for holding an 80-pound braided line is the Okuma Raw II 80.

For surf fishing, a lot more money would be required to ensure you get the proper reel. Most surf fishing reels are not made to carry more than 10 pounds of line. Its lack of strength is more likely to prevent you from catching the big ones.

However, the spinning reel is ideal for bass fishing. Its bass fishing capabilities are one of a kind, with just a range of 8 to 10 pounds of line.

The spinning reel is unique in its ways and comes with its advantages. However, it would not just do because there are a lot of species in the water that would require different equipment and techniques to catch.

You are now led to choosing other equipment if needed because the spinning reel does not meet your needs.

Taking a look at the counterpart of the spinning reel in our discussion; the casting reel, we would notice that there are significant differences between the two.

The Casting Reel

The glory of the casting reels is that they are designed for heavy duty works, whereas only a few spinning reels can try to do the same.

Casting reels are designed for heavy lures and are the ideal products for surf fishing. One downside, however, is the difficulty in learning how to use the casting reel effectively.

An example of an ideal casting reel is the Abu Garcia Black Max Reek BMAX2. It is an excellent casting reel and is a good one to learn with. It is very affordable and made with materials that are lightweight.

casting real

The downside to the Abu Garcia Black Max Reek BMAX2 is that is constructed with graphite, and it is very susceptible to saltwater corrosion.

An edge the spinning reel has due to its durable aluminum construction that can withstand saltwater corrosion.

What you need is a lightweight reel, like the spinning reel, because it is easier to fight a frantic fish with this type of reel.

One other thing to know about casting reels is that they are quite difficult to throw over a short distance, and with poor accuracy too. The reason is that you would have to stop the spool from releasing the line to avoid getting to the ever dreaded ‘bird’s nest.’

The casting reel contains more massive lines and guides at the top side of the rod, and you might not get to feel the bite of the fish with these. However, only a professional can try bass fishing with a casting reel. The spinning reel has proven itself to be the ideal reel for bass fishing.

Differences between the Spinning Reel and Casting Reel

  • The casting reel is very suitable for catching bigger species of fish such as the salmon and walleye. Using a spinning reel for larger fish species is like a wild goose chase.
  • Fishing for big species requires a heavy lure, and the rod used must be able to withstand the pressure very well. Casting reels fit this purpose very well, as the weight is spread evenly across the whole rod to balance it out. Casting reels are designed for heavy lines and long distance castings, unlike the spinning reels which are somewhat the complete opposite.
  • The casting reels are quite harder to learn than the spinning reels. Reels would only function efficiently if appropriately used, and proper use is derived from learning to use the equipment.
  • A simple citation is the presence of the longer rod in casting reels and not in the spinning reels. The longer rods make it challenging to cast under ledges or against winds. The simplicity of the spinning reel is just outstanding in this aspect.
  • There are usually backlashes when using a casting reel. Modern forms of the casting reel have tried to ensure that the backlash effect is significantly reduced. However, it persists in small amounts and gets frustrating for amateur anglers.

Finishing Line

Picking a reel for surf fishing would put the spinning reel in favor than the casting reel. From all the citations we discussed above, it is clear that it would be hard to use a casting reel for surf fishing even if you are a seasoned professional.

The casting reel is known for its ability to carry heavy lures, but fishing for bass is not a good idea with this reel. Bass gets frantic when caught, and a heavy reel would not do you any good in this situation.

We can now safely say that the spinning reel, with aluminum construction, is the most suitable reel for surf fishing.